Thanks to everyone for their feedback. Apparently, the problem is/was in the cable or the connectors. Because its so difficult to get that second connection made (at least for me), I think something wasn't made up all the way. There aren't any bent or damaged pins. I took the cluster apart (removed the upper half) enabling a much easier time of hooking it up due to smaller overall size. When I reconnected the battery, everything worked. However, when I put it back together and then reinstalled it - straining the wire harness to make the second connection, the same problem occurred. The cluster was dead and the car cut off immediately. So, I removed it and then very carefully reinstalled it, being VERY careful to insure the connections made up correctly, and everything works!
I followed turbocharged798's recommendation to re-set it each time before removing and made sure the battery was not connected each time I connected/disconnected the cluster.
I don't know how everyone else manipulates that thing to get the connections made up, but I always have a hard time getting the second one done, and am always worried I'm pulling on the wires too much. They sure didn't provide any extra length of wire!