Update: I just had questionable service at Tim's German Auto. Very nice guys, very devoted, but different philosophy.
They still recommend 5k oil changes.
They feel that overfilling the crankcase is no big deal, and we're all overreacting to it when it happens.
They charged me $410 for DSG service, which is about $80 more than just down the road.
None of this means they're completely incompetent, although I'll stick with the manufacturer's recommendation for OCI and oil volume (isn't that why there's a line on the dipstick???
Ozzmosis86: care to update your post about Arlington after your extensive experience with them? Do you still recommend them? (also, I sent you a PM. Did you receive it?)