It looked, to me, like a FMIC was a no brainer simply because the OEM sidemount ,on a Golf, has a very small fresh air supply going into it and the inlet piping looks horribly restrictive. My choice was the Eurojet FMIC kit from Kerma. It has a 24"-10"-2" core. I like the resonably free flowing 2" of thickness. I read somewhere that the first 2" of thickness did 80% of the cooling - another reason for a 2" core. The core extends up to the top of the inside of the bumper, so I drilled holes across the bumper cover to expose the top 5" of IC. Fan or no fan on sidemount have a small fraction of the cooling air supply to them compaired to the Eurojet. The IC piping seems an appropiate 2" dia. As far as coolant temps, 90* seems about tops during the summer. I wondered if lag would be noticable over the OEM IC, but there was no difference.
That's my take on it, for what it's worth.