Only chiming in again because my experience is 100% the opposite of dhangejr, although I couldn't understand all of the post.
You agreed with me for saying your exp is 100% opposite.
I enjoy the topic and have a good amount of knowledge to share and im a nerd
To be clear, I agree I had great luck just polishing most of my friends headlamps with a rotary and some cheap plastic polish. Once the uv has started peeling you do need to scratch it off and make the scratches smooth. I have lots to say about that too too.
For me, far as poly vs glass goes, its up for debate for sure.
What I know is if they are both in good condition they are equal as far as performance. (check HID PLANET)
The MK4 jetta is 80 for glass 40 for poly made by depo on ebay. Im a complete nerd lol did not even have to look that up (EBAY).
Whats a fact is laminx does affect your output be it on plastic or glass.(HID PLANET)
So that makes glass inferior because it bacically needs a cover or you will replace them sooner than the plastic. It resits pitting much better than glass or metal actaully. HOw I know? Two of my cars are salt and peppered badly from speeding and the tiny rocks on the ****ty i5 here, the one with glass lenese needed replaced (e36 m3) due to pitting but the plastic lenses are not pitted.
***Ultimately, to me 80$ for glass lenses then 30$ for laminex is a HUGE waste of money! you will get zero gains!
However, you will get HUGE YES HUGE EFFIN gains from swapping in a high quality projector, with quality bulbs and ballasts...this costs about as much as glass lenses and lamin-x lol...
D2s projector or bust BTW the performance difference is HUGE once again...people cheap out on this part too often haha DON"T DO IT. you get what you pay for. Personally im loving NHK led projectors i have right now but im not sure they will last as long as the high quality HID projectors do.
Just more random BS cuz im enmeshed into the topic in other places right now. lol
I do believe companies like to make money by saving money but companies like Mercedes, BMW and AUDI like to make money by having the BEST tech, so if glass made their headlights have an advantage they would be using it as the norm, but they don't. The fact that they have been steadily upgrading their headlamps for the last 25 years is proof. I still LOVE the OEM hella ballists and many junkies do.
On Older cars glass lens were very common and today there very rare.
BTW most of those lens are fluted and I do believe plastic is inferior for that design. In fact, MY z3 has decent headlights stock TBH old design but inside it there are two plastic lenses they feel like glass tho. THey diffuse the light and the output on that car is closer to that of the bora e-codes, but still the z3 high beam stomps the bora's too. My moms old maxima has glass lights and they SUCK but I think the reflectors are burnt out.
As far as older cars with glass lenses many are still in great condition! so it does depend on the quality. the mentioned maxima being one of em. But in general they break easier than plastic. We have a basement full of older glass headlamps form my grnadpas old cars lol they broke often. all of em are fluted too..
PS
PS hid planet like i said ironically this is mk4 the video is not avalable but read post 6 you get the idea he sent the glass back for his used ome plasic.
https://www.hidplanet.com/forums/fo...ons/61971-headlight-lens-clarity-a-comparison
Get answers and advice on questions related to your specific project
www.hidplanet.com