Fix_Until_Broke
Top Post Dawg
Ok - some back story before the "rest of the story..."Loaded it on the trailer...
Stay tuned for the "rest of the story..."
The above Roadmaster wasn't out of winter storage yet so was going to use the Jetta to pick up some items for a friend of mine using my smaller trailer (lots of pics in the towing thread). I've been daily driving the Jetta all winter, no issues other than a starter and battery that were replaced. The Jetta sat for the month of April as I drove a different vehicle for a while - drove it to it's parking spot, no indications that anything was amiss.
So, go to start the Jetta the night before the trip with the trailer, key on, cranks over fine, fires up a bit rough/stumble (normal), runs on all cylinders for ~15 seconds then dies. Hmm - that's weird...
Hit the starter again and it cranks over super fast and easy, doesn't start. Uh oh... Try it again, same thing. ***?
Start checking things - can't find anything wrong, timing belt is good, tensioner is good, no lifters are spidered, etc
Grab the compression gauge - 150 psi in 3 of 4 cylinders (didn't do #4 because it's a hassle to get to and with the results of the previous 3, doesn't really matter anyway...)
So, because I'm spoiled with a good friend that let's me use his shop with a hoist, I drive the other vehicle to get my Roadmaster out of storage, borrow my uncles trailer (shown above), bring that home with my other car on the trailer, push the Jetta on the trailer to take it to my friends shop to dig into it deeper. I don't know what's wrong, but I don't want to tear into this outside in my driveway.
Get to my friends shop, double check everything, cam/IP/Crank timing are spot on, another lifter check, pull the crank damper pulley, no issues with the timing belt - can't find any reason that it has 150psi compression.
On a lark, try to start it again and it starts to catch, then a bit more, then running on it's own (2 cylinders maybe), and after a few more seconds on all 4 cylinders. It starts to stumble and die again, but saves itself and keeps running. So, put everything back together, clean up my tools, take it out for some "exercise" and it runs fine. Shut it off, restarts fine. Let it sit overnight, starts right up the next morning. So, load it back up on the trailer and bring it home. Did a compression test tonight and got ~380 psi on the same 3/4 cylinders (cold engine, 18:1 CR, Stage 2 Cam installed straight up, etc)
Best guess is that the rings got "sticky" and were not sealing well, therefore low compression, sounds like it's freewheeling when cranking and no start.
My friend says he's had this happen 2 times in 40 years on diesels - Both were manual transmission trucks and was able to tow them in gear to get them spinning fast enough to make enough heat to start combustion. One of them was 10+ years ago and still runs fine today.
I was expecting to find something catastrophic and for it to be the end of the line for this car, but not yet .
As the late Paul Harvey would say..."now you know, the rest of the story"