The repair is complete but the MIL is still on. Dealership said they could drive it another 100-150 miles over the next 3-5 days and then I can pickup or I can do the miles. I am going to pick it up and see what happens. My thought was to clear the light and then see if it comes back. Any thoughts?
Wait, they didn't clear it or drive it to make sure it was clear?
a) Are you in one of their loaners?
b) Is the dealership easy to get to for you?
If you're in a loaner (as I was 5x over emissions) and it's inconvenient to get back to the dealership then I would tell them to fix it and you'll get you car back when it's fully fixed.
If you take the car back, it's not fixed, you clear because tired of seeing MIL on and it comes back on, the saga starts all over again. Also, idk how many miles you had left on your warranty but if you go over and car isn't fixed from this, I'd want as much leverage as I could get to make sure the car is fully fixed before VWoA tells you that you're on your own.
