@marcboxx At the risk of going off topic, the issues you describe with a replacement ECM are a mix of ECU and BCM controlled functions. What is being replaced?
An ECU from another car won't work without doing an immo adaptation at minimum. Engine will start then immediately turn off.
A BCM from another car will have no impact on how the engine runs, although lots of other functions will be weird/wrong/not working until you match coding and adaptations.
In a quick search I found used ECU for under $200 and used BCM under $100. Dealer process to flash, adapt immo & component protection, code and parameterize is the same used or new. All of it is done via guided function. Labor rates can vary wildly but I paid 3 hours labor for BCM replacement. I would expect to pay the same for ECU. The physical replacement is easier, and coding will be marginally quicker but there's still the time to get the car in the bay and connected to consider.
Then again there's also real value in the convenience of dropping your car off and then getting it back in working order. My intention isn't to persuade either way, just providing info for folks that might be in a similar situation.
Yes, all solid points in fact! I went the way you describe locating a comparable working unit from Ebay from another 2015 TDI “SE” MK7 but finding the costs all over the place with no guarantees of successful service outside the factory / dealer network. What I’ve found utilizing a source out of Ft Myers, FL called ECU Maverick is that while they had success in bypassing the IMMO which in turn allowed the engine to start, run and drive without issue. They were not successful in reprogramming my VIN into the used unit. This in turn produces all the warning lights and symptoms mentioned in previous post. The cost was marginal at $400 + UPS or FedEx traceable shipping. Yet the time spent with having the car down so long and the procedure not effectively solving ALL the problems on both the first and YES the 2nd try (they sent a backup unit which did not start the car at all) were enough for me to resort to getting things done right by way the dealer w/ suppprt from VW AG in Germany.
Clearlake VW (my primary servicing dealer during Dieselgate warranty term) has had 3 TDI’s in in the last 2 months with same issues. Once a new one was installed with full factory flash they are all running as factory delivered. Heading on another 6,000 mile road-trip in August and quite frankly prefer that piece of mind over going the used ECM and praying
for a miracle reflash from either and outside party or the dealer.
The dealer will charge you $350 to perform the reflash on a used ECM with no guarantees it will work at 50-50. They will then charge the full amount to obtain a new one from Germany and flash it with the factory VAG setting for the additional $1,600 to $1,800. Just not worth the risk and added expense as I’ve gone through this now myself with no success.
The MK7 version of the TDI is beginning a cycle of difficulty in being fully supported in the US outside the 130,000 mile Dieselgate warranty. My primary mechanic who himself has a full VAG system in his shop could not successfully determine how to deal with the ECM once it had failed to even communicate. This resulted in a diagnosis of the ECM needing replacement.
Added to the above, replacement parts
have been quite expensive and very difficult to source locally either via the dealer network or wholesale outlets nationwide.
Many times I’ve resorted to Europe for more expensive hard to get items usually from VW “factory test vehicles” with little to no mileage on them parted out for penny’s in the dollar compared to US prices and limited stock options.
In a nutshell, she is still loved and I feel like after the work I’ve put in the last 3+ yrs she is in a better position now to deliver 500,000 miles if I keep her that long.
The only things not changed to this point and remain original to the vehicle have been:
1. the physical diesel motor and some of it’s primary components (tranny would have lasted sans the hole from errant road debris),
2. the complete exhaust and emissions / DEF systems,
3. one of TWO radiators (yes we have 2 coupled together as primary and secondary units), and
4. the interior dash related components /in the cabin.
What I will say is that each vehicle will be hit and miss depending on the mileage and level of care. But without a doubt I do believe there is a level of planned obsolescence built into some of the systems and parts of the MK7 one will have to consider over its lifespan.
I still love mine because it’s unique, Uber fuel efficient and in a world now where electric cars are not yet viable choice options for long distance journeys and prices on new cars and interest rates are at an all time high. I recommend still investing in your TDI until she either gives up the ghost or inflation diminishes acceptably enough to consider replacement options.