Well,
I live in Central PA and I've owned a Wrangler for the majority of my driving experience (I'm 25). So I've always had a 4wd because I always thought I needed one. Love driving a Wrangler, but they just aren't everyday driving material (lifted, of course) being that they get 13mpg city/13mpg highway. Owned a '04 Wrangler 4-banger, 4" lift and 33" tires. Thing was an absolute dog, but it was amazing on the trail. Latest was an '05 Rubicon, 2" lift with 31" tires. Again, loved driving it but ~230mi. range on gas SUCKED.
I'm about to graduate college and I was planning on buying something new over the summer, but I was planning on it being a four-door Wrangler. Long story short, they are f'n expensive, and practically the same fuel effeciency.
Went to Florida with my dad over Spring break and ended up with a '15 Jetta SE as a rental. Drove the thing something like 1300 miles around Florida. Absolutley LOVED it. Kept telling myself if I didn't need 4wd, I'd be buying one (winter is pretty harsh and I live on a mountain).
So anyways, I'm looking at Wranglers online, and I decided to check out what a '15 Jetta runs, just for ****s and giggles. Started looking at Jetta SE's and was amazed by how relatively cheap they were for the price. Went to Jetta TDI SE's, and then it snowballed from there. Realized a TDI SEL was within my price range and I figured if I'm buying new, I might as well get exactly what I want. Went with a '15 Jetta TDI SEL with Lighting & Driver Convenience package in Platinum Gray with 6MT (had to get a manual; Wranglers got me hooked on a manual transmission).
I've had it about 2 weeks now. Got a pretty good deal on it. MSPR @28,992. Financed @26,300 after everything. Averaging 42mpg since I've had it. Couldn't be happier. I'll be interested to see what winter is like, but I plan on buying some studded tires (looking for advice on winter tires, btw) for the front.
So yeah, that's my story. Would definitely recommend TDI's to anyone and everyone. Fun to drive, amazing effeciency (~600mi range), beautiful car inside and out, plus you just cannot beat that new car smell.