I've owned an 82 S-10, a 03 Avalanche, and now a 07 Canyon. I've had less combined issues with those three than I did in my ten years of owning my 2000 TDI beetle.
Well said, experiences do vary, but I've had good and bad cars from GM, and the VW Jetta, it was mostly good, but had the crappy HPFP that was put there to save $600 per car, they cheated emissions to save about $300 per car.. what other corners did VW cut? Look, I liked the Jetta, the DSG for an auto was great, they have their good, but they also have bad. Same for all OEMs. To express blind brand loyalty is foolish, but many do this. Be objective about this and be honest, that is a rare trait these days it seems. I still have a now 20 year old GM (Saturn) with nearly 200K and minimal work over that time.. Not all GM is bad, and not all VW is good. The Jetta I ditched was a 2012, LNT, and it had metal in the fuel filter, and VW said that was OK and charged me to do nothing!? That is extremely poor customer service, and outright kicking the can down the road, they were happy to gamble with an unpredictable total HPFP failure that would leave my wife stranded, and I was NOT. That is the primary reason I had to ditch that car. In contrast, one of my now 2 Cruze Diesels had a mis-fuel with the prior owner, and guess what, no catastrophic HPFP failure, all they did was pump the tank and reset the MIL and it runs fine, that would KILL a VW, by their own admission (to cover up the fact they chose the cheaper failure prone pump to save $600, kind of like they lied for years about the emissions until forced to come clean when EPA refused certification of the 2015 cars that were held at dock)... don't fool yourself to think VW is perfect, and GM is evil, they both do bad and good, and neither are perfect, but GM appears to be making improvements, and I'm not sure VW is, yet, but I hope they do clean up their act, competition is good for the customer, and we should be objective and reward the OEMs who do good, and not the ones doing bad, and realize this will change over time. I would consider a VW at some point in the future, I'm not against them forever, but I would do so knowing full well of the issues that could exist in an honest way.. in the near term, not likely especially as they are going away from Diesel to appease the anti-internal combustion engine regulators to pay penance for there sins with the emissions cheat.