Fully agree. I really loved the VW product and the temptation is there, but I dont need that drama for a primary car. We're probably looking to get another used Mazda CX5 CX9 or maybe a CX3. I have to deep dive on the reliability, but the Mazda we have has been really solid and I like that the engine compartment is not buried in a ton of ****. Dont want a turbo either. The 2.5L Mazda/Ford motor seems to be pretty solid. I know the 2.0L has held up well. I can still love my MK5's and I will never get rid of two remaining, since I have a ton of service parts for them. The wifey just wants something newer and while I consider the MK5 fairly solid, I worry about sending her down the road and having an issue.The issues with the warranty:
A: not much left anymore, regardless of which model/year
B: as you already mentioned, VoA doesn't like to honor their agreement
C: cars are MUCH more likely to have warrantable things break, which I think came as a surprise to them
D: parts availability is spotty, some people wait for a year or more, one guy piled up over $9k on rental cars while he waited
E: warranty or not, the car is still the same car
Thanks again OH, appreciate your knowledge and advice.