Admission time
I actually value my Tacoma more than the Jetta TDI, so my choice is for it to be in the garage, along with my wife's car. I bought my black Tacoma 4×4 new in 2003, and it's been our third vehicle (yes, I'm spoiled/blessed) ever since. I have less than 24,000 miles on it, and plan to keep it for a very long time, Lord willing. Also, because we lived in Deutschland in 2007 for my work, the Tacoma and my wife's car didn't see any mileage, as they were stored on jack stands. I bought the Jetta TDI five days after I returned from the Fatherland.
So, the Jetta is relegated to the outdoors to shiver (she's covered with a new blanket of snow right now). I do have a Frost Heater, so the engine starts right up when I use that, and if needed, I have a very long, low-gauge extension cord to reach the Jetta in the far corner of my driveway (best place when snow throwing). Besides, the Jetta is much easier to clear the snow off of compared to the Tacoma with its height (I'm a short 5' 7"; my parents fault) and it Tonneau cover. Also, the book value on my Tacoma is much more than the Jetta, even though they are the same age.
Ideally, I want to build a workshop/New England country barn out back with an additional one bay garage. But, that's a few years away, if ever.