Rob Mayercik
Veteran Member
Yep, on the ALH cars it was always about a 5MPG bonus for the stick vs. the automatic.That's a manual versus automatic thing. Rob's tank range with an automatic is very good. Mine with a manual is just OK. I drive too fast to get really good range, at least most of the time.
I've always seen a bit of a dropoff in MPG the higher I go above 70 on the speedo myself, so I know where you're coming from with the "driving too fast" bit, IBW. The tank I showed above, I averaged around 70 on the highway miles, seems to be the sweet spot for me right now.
Back when I was still on the smaller stock nozzles I was averaging 44-45MPG under similar conditions (and even have two documented tanks at 47MPG).
To the O/P, I am glad the wife vetoed those "procedures" your shop recommended (since I doubt they will buy you dinner for that price, or ever call you later ).
IBW's probably right, the cooler temps are probably slowing the warmup (so maybe the pipe insulation grille block might help), but what pressure are you running on the tires now? I've always had tires whose sidewall max was 44 or 51, and I have found with my MKIV that around 38-40 was around optimum for ride/handling/grip/MPG. I recently had a rotation done and the shop that did it dropped me to 32PSI, which I only caught because I noticed a 1-2MPG hit at the next fill-up.
Another thing to check for is sticking brakes (at least the MKIVs are notorious for the parking brake mechanism in the rear calipers getting stuck and causing dragging) - a light drag can sap an MPG or two without being too noticeable in drivability. Of course, being winter it could have iced up too...