They just are not nearly as useful as my hatchbacks and wagons. If I had to have one car, it would never ever be a sedan.
Agreed. In fact even the Golf Hatch I started to find limiting in capacity. We will soon in fact need two wagons for logistical reasons (long story). I was worried about being able to get a 3-pedal wagon when the need will be real (2019), so I bit the bullet and bought a manual GSW on Jan. 23d; a 6-MT 4MOTION. Not as efficient as a TDI (29 mpg so far in winter), or even my previous TSI hatch (40 mpg in summer, 36 in winter) by a long shot, but being retired, that was no longer a major consideration. What was more important is that I have to drive about 80 km a week on a very poorly maintained road that has been ice/snow covered all winter (in spite of being paved) and much of last winter as well.
I disagree. My recollection was that when the MKIV was launched people praised it's "nearly Audi-like" interior and how much more modern it was than the cobbled together MKIII it replaced. The MKIV Jetta Sedan literally saved VW in this market by being a nice European design car at a reasonable price. Response to the '11 Jetta Sedan was much more critical.
Agreed, I had an old issue of CAR magazine singing the praises of the Mk IV Golf when it came out, how it looked like a much more expensive car than it was. I had an early (99) Mk IV Jetta TDI, and was impressed by the build quality. Reliability was another matter though, the early Mk IVs were terrible! It was my intro to VWs and I went back to Honda for a while after that but really missed the VW "je ne sais quoi", and got a Mk IV TDI wagon in '04, and my wife and I have been exclusively VW since. The Mk IV wagon was my favourite VW by far, alas it got totalled at 110k km in '06 (lots of commuting in those days).
Last fall, my son bought a Mk IV Jetta wagon... but a 2.slow, used, for $1.9k and quite a bit of rust, but a great runner. A TDI was either twice the price, or twice the KM (he has 269k km on it). It does look dated now compared to my Mk VII, but it still ain't bad except for the rust.