Ok before I go too crazy with all this let me stop and think for a second. What are the actual troubleshooting steps for this issue?...i guess it would fall under idle speed incorrect rough or irregular. The bentley touches on troubleshooting but doesnt really give any procedures of what to do. for instance "probable cause": faulty injection pump; "corrective action": replace pump. Really? I would have never guessed that. So how do I get to that point. I'm still not 100% certain the the throttle position sensor has nothing to do with it either. I need some definitive troubleshooting guides and steps before I start throwing too much time and $ at the problem at hand.
Per Bentley:
A. pedal isnt attached to anything so its not binding
B./C. All fuel lines including hard lines and fuel filter are brand new and were carefully installed
D. Kerma just rebuilt these injectors
E. timing is as close as i can get it while checking vagcom and engine idling at 1200 RPMS
F. Have not done a compression test but I could. complete engine is fresh build from Frank
G. We know about the plunger sticking and I probably need to investigate some more. I have tried searching the forums, is there a write up anywhere of how to tear down and rebuild this pump or is this something I should leave to the "professionals". (i have a viton seal kit should be here before the weekend)
Then under "engine runs at a high constant idle and speed does not vary"
A. no faults in vagcom; how do I verify the pento is not causing this?
I hate just swapping out parts as a "troubleshooting" step but I do have access to another pump. I do not have access to another pedal. If I can not figure out how to actually troubleshoot the pump, I may swap it out to see the results.
Is what I observed so far proof enough that the pump needs rebuild?
How do I rule out a wonky ECM/Tune?
jimbote, growler, and greengeeker, I really appreciate all the advice so far. This van needs to be on the road!
EDIT:
http://forums.tdiclub.com/showthread.php?t=245955 <==Very interesting read. Still no clue whats going on with mine hehe