Ok, thanks guys. Well you asked (and I appreciate it), but below is the symptoms and what I've done:
The problem started out of the blue coming back from work it suddenly began bucking and blowing heavy black smoke. At start-up it barely runs and surges wildly (no codes) but a huge plume of smoke that could swollow a house! Trying to accelerate in park (or drive too) ...the engine doesn't want to accelerate and engine chuggs and blows copius amounts of smoke. But if ya floor it, it'll increase in RPM and smooth out (but engulf the whole house in smoke). If I drive it, and more or less floor it, it'll take off and smooth out at high rpm ..and eventually when warm will idle perfect and run out smooth (no codes initially). If I shut it off and instantly restart it, it'll run rough again and if I accelerate hard up to high rpm it'll smooth out again. Probably running in limp mode. Car has 235k Mi, auto tranny (rebuilt). I dont' have the Vagcom. Here's what I've done:
1) New turbo assembly (cause of miles mostly). Made no difference. Turbo vanes on old unit loosened up with some work when removed. After the fact, I'm sure I could have run it longer, but I already had the new turbo and just put it on anyway rather than wait for old one to crap out in the deep of winter.
2) New EGR (no difference)
3) Cleaned intake and all turbo pipes, inner cooler. They weren't bad.
3.5) New fuel and air filters. Cleaned snow screen.
4) Checked cam/lifters (all good)
5) Replaced all vacuum hoses (no I didn't get any crossed or mixed up. I quadruple-checked with a diagram. No leaks that I can find. Check valve good. 25psi vacuum. Didn't see any leaks around brake booster pipe.
6) Replaced N75 with new VW unit (also swapped it around N18). No difference
7) Pressure tested turbo and piping. I only used about 8psi on entire system. Found minor leak on hose coming out of turbo where clamp cut into hose. I trimmed it back and is good now. (this has made start-up smoother. Idles better on start-up but still blows major smoke and chuggs when accelerator is depressed until about 2000 rpm then starts to level off).
8) VNT is new, doesn't leak .
9) If I actuate the VNT manually when accelerating it seems to accelerate properly, run properly. Doesn't chug or hesitate.
10) Did not change MAF. It runs worse when unplugged
11) Temp sensor was replaced 2x yrs ago when Timing belt was replaced (Jason TDI did it).
12) Cleaned all battery and ground connections.
13) Read a ton of crap on the forums and pretty much followed all that I could find.
When warm it'll idle great all day long and accelerate, drives out ok, therefore I don't think it's fuel system related. So as far as I can tell, it comes down to whatever key components are controlling the vacuum of the N75. As the engine accelerates, the vacuum to the VNT goes down. This is testing in the driveway.
I could replace the MAF/MAP, but I don't have any way to measure at the moment and thought I'd get your thoughts what might be behind the N75 signal.
So, what are your thoughts? I don't know that want to start down the VAGcom route ...I have so many other car projects/family/work/Home restoration, etc. I know Jason Daniels and I might ready to take it to him (he's been busy though). He offered some suggestions. I thought I might get it resolved more easily, but don't want to keep going down the new parts scattergun approach, which I don't usually like to do. Most everything I've done already, as I see it, probably needed to be done anyway to keep a reliable vehicle.
Your thoughts and ideas more than welcome. Thanks
Gruni