One of the reasons I got the 17" wheels was for better MPG.
I've seen this type of comment before, and have searched through the historical threads on the forum. I know that the theory is that the wheels weigh less, the tires are less wide, therefore the tires have less contact surface area on the road, thus less resistance and henceforth better mileage.
I put 16" winter tires on my car this past winter. Because I went from 235/45/18's to 215/60/16's, i calculated that the original tire circumference was 82.7in and the snow tires were 82.2. So, that means my speedo was about 0.6% fast. Therefore, at 60mph, I would really be doing 59.6mph. And this also means that my odometer would read 0.6% fast too meaning that my car will say that it went 100 miles, when it really only went 99.x. My speed calcs also seemed to jive with this calculator (
http://www.myturbodiesel.com/1000q/tire-wheel-gearing-calculator.htm), which said I would have a -0.65% speed difference with my snow tires and wheels.
I've seen the posts where people claim a 3-4MPG swing from 18" wheels and tires to 17" wheels and tires. I've also read where VeeDubTDI says you can expect nearly 10% difference...which is probably right around 4MPG. This just seems like too much to me. I'm having a hard time buying it.
For those who have seen this much change
1. Are you running the same tires or tires with practically the same rolling resistance when you measured this difference?
2. How many tanks overall did you measure the change with? I could see 1-2 tanks being skewed just from subconsciously driving differently knowing that you want to see your mileage go up.
3. Any temperature changes that might result in this mileage change. For example, if I changed tires in the spring, it would appear as if my miles were going way up from the tires, when really it's just ambient weather helping out.
I don't completely have my head in the sand, I could see being able to prove some amount of difference. But 10% or 3-4mpg seems too hard to believe simply going from 18" tires to 17" tires. I do realize that smaller wheels and smaller tires weight less...but we are talking about a 3400lb car, how much difference does 10lbs at each corner make. Certainly not 10%, right?
Anyway, just curious to see what people think.