OK. Just got back. It is definately a 5 speed. They only have one.
Talked to Karlreese Sims. Took some pictures. Drove it. It has heated seats, sun roof, Monsoon sound system, retractable cover over the rear area, grey cloth seats.
The condition. Overall the body is in good shape. A couple scuffs on the hood, none down to bear metal. Tires look brand new. Brake pads look farily new from looking from the outside of the wheels. The battery cover is present as is the belly pan. Both look in good shape.
Drives good. Might need some struts. It does have 60,000 miles on it. Clutch and shifter was very smooth.
Karl kept telling me he had a lot of interest. I told him that it was because Autotrader listed it as automatic.
Basically, my recommendation would be offer $14K and go up to $14.5K. I would go higher if they threw in a warranty of some sort. Make sure it is a VW service contract and not a 3rd party one.