I took our 05 in for drivers side fender lip rust. Got approved by VOA. Was told to bring it to the dealers 3rd party bodyshop. I called the shop to inquire if they would be using an OEM fender and was told that a spot repair was approved, Not a new fender. Called the dealer back and gave him a tongue lashing. Told him I would not approve them welding in a patch or using bondo. He gave me some bull about the fender being very expensive and that VW would not approve such an expenditure. I notified him that a new OEM fender could be had for $156.00 with 2 day shipping and to stop being so cheap. They refused to cooperate so I just bought the fender myself and will have it painted and installed at my body shop. Hopefully I will be able to get reimbursed by VOA afterwards. My dealer is Heart VW in Kingston, NY and so you all know, THEY SUCK.