It will take a while to recoup the "saved fuel" costs with the DPF delete.
Using my 2010 A3 TDI as an example,
prior to delete, ~40mpg combined fuel efficiency (80hwy/20city), I have a lead foot on the highway and a bit pokey in town. 100k miles on the car prior to delete. At the time, diesel averaged $3.80/gal, so according to my math comes out to $0.095/mile.
after delete, 43mpg combined fuel efficiency, same 80/20 split. So far I have 150k miles on the car after the delete, and fuel costs have also dropped dramatically, to an average of $2.90/gal over that time frame. $0.067/mile.
Assuming I had not done the delete and continued with the prior efficiency while taking into account the drop in fuel pricing, I have thus far "saved" $759.
Cost of the DPF delete at the time was $800 for the down and mid pipes, $1k for the stage 2 and DSG tunes, labor was free. So I still have abit over $1k, or 200,000 miles to go until the DPF delete costs are recouped. In my case, driving the car 450k miles, four timing belt changes, countless sets of tires, brake pads, struts, etc..
of course that time frame is shortened up if fuel prices spike.