Asphaltene in Diesel Fuel

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
I posted this in someone's TDI101 fuel filter question but I wanted to start a new thread specific to this question.

The fuel filter I changed in December on my 05 Golf (PD) had black fuel drain out of it. It turns out my in-tank lift pump was dead as well, so when I changed that out last month, I got to see the inside of my fuel tank. It was coated in black stuff like what I could see inside the fuel filter hole. Also, there were some drops of brown water inside of the dead lift pump that I noticed when I emptied the fuel out of it into a bucket.

I have been running the car on diesel with 5% biodiesel for the last year and have also included 4oz of Stanadyne Performance formula with every fill up for about two years. That stuff is supposed to take care of water by making it separate out easier in the fuel filter, but now I am wondering if it just makes it separate out easier into the fuel tank. In either event, I was also driving around for probably 3,000 miles, at least, with a dead lift pump. I think I read somewhere that a dead lift pump situation may contribute to excessive heating of the fuel (I'm not sure about this last one). Here is a website that I found that discusses the issues of heat and its effect on creating asphaltenes:
http://fuelschool.blogspot.com/2009/...l-filters.html

For comparison, I also recently changed the fuel filter and inspected the inside of my 02 Beetle (VE) fuel tank. The fuel filter looked much cleaner than the PD filter and the fuel tank looked clean. The tank was white-ish inside, no black deposits. The fuel filter was about the same age as the Golf filter and both cars had been run on the same fuel: B5 plus Stanadyne. So I'm thinking that my PD car heated the fuel a lot more than VE car creating the asphaltene issue. Having a dead lift pump in the PD might also have contributed to the issue.

My questions are:
Should I try to clean out my PD fuel tank by wiping it down or putting some chemical in the tank (any suggestions)?

Does it matter if I do nothing? Will the fuel filter just take care of it?

Will this stuff dissolve back into the fuel and maybe clean itself up with time now that I might have less of a heat issue (working lift pump in the tank now)?

Right now I have Chevron fuel with TechronD in the tank. Any insight appreciated. Thanks.
 

Powder Hound

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Oct 25, 1999
Location
Under a Bridge, Crestview, FL, USA
TDI
'00 Golf 4dr White 5sp, '02 Jettachero 5sp, Wife's '03 NB Platinum Gray auto(!)
I don't know if those little guys are as sticky as asphalt, but I would think that leaving them in a particulate state that would allow them to be pumped to and collected by the filter would be best. I also think your theory about excess heat causing more asphaltines is probably correct, but I'm not an organic chemist, so I can't speak to that directly.
 

DanG144

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Location
Chapin, South Carolina, USA
TDI
2005 A4 Jetta 5spd
I can tell you that most PD tanks I look into have a black carbon looking coating on them.

Know one seems to know if it is from the carbon in the fuel pump brushes, organic growth, or some chemical reaction, and some seem to think that it is from leaking injector seals and orings.

Since I have never seen exhaust gasses bubbling in the return line, I think it is not injector seals.

I wipe the inside down with lint free towels, vacuum the fuel out. Ensure NO water is left inside.

Then I routinely treat with Power Service Diesel Fuel Supplement to solubilize the water, and treat about 4 times a year with PS BIOKLEEN to kill organics.

If you keep the water out, the organic growth rate is greatly reduced.
 

RalphVa

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Location
Virginia
TDI
Jetta
What you're finding in your older car's tank is probably tiny bits of aromatics that oxidized to some black material. With ULSD and the extra processing that it experiences (probably a final heavy hydrotreat), the aromatics are all but gone with the sulfur. What many will be running into is more wax formation.

I recently had troubles with my tractor cutting out as though it had water in the diesel. I changed out the fuel filter a couple of times and even got fresh fuel. Still had the problem. So, I siphoned out that fresh fuel from the tank.

What I found were some whitish/yellowish globs of (probably) wax near the outlet hole for the line from the tank. I fished them out with a grabber tool and discarded them. Refilled the tank and no problems since.

About the only thing that would dissolve these wax particles are 1) use additives to keep them from forming in the first place, 2) warm up the fuel or dissolve with warm kerosene. Kerosene will have far more solubility for the wax particles than diesel. You won't get the wax out short of waiting for summer unless you practice #1 or do #2. #3 is what I did, which is much more difficult in a car tank.
 

DanG144

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Location
Chapin, South Carolina, USA
TDI
2005 A4 Jetta 5spd
RalphVa said:
What you're finding in your older car's tank is probably tiny bits of aromatics that oxidized to some black material. With ULSD and the extra processing that it experiences (probably a final heavy hydrotreat), the aromatics are all but gone with the sulfur. What many will be running into is more wax formation.

I recently had troubles with my tractor cutting out as though it had water in the diesel. I changed out the fuel filter a couple of times and even got fresh fuel. Still had the problem. So, I siphoned out that fresh fuel from the tank.

What I found were some whitish/yellowish globs of (probably) wax near the outlet hole for the line from the tank. I fished them out with a grabber tool and discarded them. Refilled the tank and no problems since.

About the only thing that would dissolve these wax particles are 1) use additives to keep them from forming in the first place, 2) warm up the fuel or dissolve with warm kerosene. Kerosene will have far more solubility for the wax particles than diesel. You won't get the wax out short of waiting for summer unless you practice #1 or do #2. #3 is what I did, which is much more difficult in a car tank.
I think that it is just as likely organic growth. I have seen black thread-like growth and clear jelly fish-like growth, especially in diesel tractor tanks or farm fuel supply tanks.

Use a biocide such as Power Service BioKleen. I can buy it at Tractor Supply Company locally, before that I got it at the fuel distributor's office.
 

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
Thanks for the replies. Since I don't really feel like opening up my fuel tank soon, I am going to try just sticking with the Chevron fuel with the TechronD in it and maybe adding some Power Service. Maybe I will also put a can of Diesel purge in the tank every once and while for the extra detergent. Since this sounds pretty common in PD fuel tanks, maybe it is not something that is too much of a concern. Also, hopefully having a working lift pump will help keep the fuel from getting as hot and increasing the black stuff formation (assuming that is what contributed to it). I will look in the fuel tank some time (or sooner if my fuel filter prematurely clogs) and see if this approach is helping. If not, I will just wipe it out (lint free towels) and work to prevent it from happening again.
 

b4black

Veteran Member
Joined
Dec 18, 2004
Location
IL
TDI
1998 Jetta blue
Asphaltenes is a name misapplied to black stuff found in diesel fuel. Asphaltenes would be huge molecules used for making bitumen and asphalt. They are not in diesel fuel.

Hydrocarbons in diesel fuel will oxidize and form gums and black particualtes. This is probably what you are seeing. Actaully, they are more likely from the 5% biodiesel than the ULSD.
 

MethylEster

Veteran Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2004
Location
Lakeville, MN
TDI
Jetta, 1999.5. Red, 5 Spd
Geomorph,

Do you buy the B5 at the Chevron station or do you " splash blend " your own ? I don't know if California has a B5 minimum spec like Minnesota does or not.

If you are splash blending, where are you buying the bio from ?
 

740GLE

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Aug 19, 2009
Location
NH
TDI
2015 Passat SEL, 2017 Alltrack SE; BB 2010 Sedan Man; 2012 Passat,
should one who uses B5 use a biocide to prevent this? or is higher Bio use more likly to have problems?
 

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
MethylEster said:
Geomorph,

Do you buy the B5 at the Chevron station or do you " splash blend " your own ? I don't know if California has a B5 minimum spec like Minnesota does or not.

If you are splash blending, where are you buying the bio from ?
I buy my B5 at a station called Propel Biofuels that have several stations set up in my area. They also sell E85. So the B5 is pre-mixed and I don't have to do any splash blending. Here is their website: http://www.propelfuels.com/content/ California does not have any biodiesel in diesel fuel minimum spec like Minnesota. The station I usually go to is not out of my way since I pass it on my way to work. Anyway, I was filling up the 02 Beetle today and there were some guys from Propel at the pump (one was giving another a tour) so I asked about where their biodiesel came from and he said they get it from all over depending on price and that it is most often from recycled waste oil and is often a mix of various sources. They get their regular diesel from the same terminal as all the other stations in the area.

The Chevron fuel (with no Biodiesel) I am using in the 05 Golf right now because I was curious whether that little bit of Bio was contributing to the black deposits in its tank. I think it is interesting that I was running both of these cars on the B5 and the black stuff only showed up in the PD's fuel system. I think the other important ingredient is heating of the fuel. I know that my PD gets the return fuel a lot hotter than the VE since I have done diesel purges on both cars. It took me a few tries to do a full diesel purge on the PD because the return fuel got so hot. I ended up setting the can of diesel purge (with the fuel lines hooked up to it) in a bucket of ice and it worked like a charm. I also wonder if running with a dead lift pump for a few thousand miles resulted in even higher temperatures than normal and that contributed to the black stuff formation.

So I am taking the B5 out of the PD for now and have a working lift pump and will see if that helps the situation.
 

DanG144

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Location
Chapin, South Carolina, USA
TDI
2005 A4 Jetta 5spd
The fuel system turned black in PD's with straight ULSD. BioD is rare here. You have to go searching for it.

I did not start mixing B2 into the 05 until a few months ago. The filter and tank has always been black as a coal mine. I was curious to see if it would clean up with B2!
 

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
DanG144 said:
The fuel system turned black in PD's with straight ULSD. BioD is rare here. You have to go searching for it.

I did not start mixing B2 into the 05 until a few months ago. The filter and tank has always been black as a coal mine. I was curious to see if it would clean up with B2!
From what you are seeing, do you think there is any correlation with dead lift pumps? Are you seeing the black stuff on cars with both working and dead lift pumps? This fuel filter was the first time I drained fuel that I did not want to put it back in the tank (because it was so dark) and I also happened to have a dead lift pump.

I don't think the bio is the main culprit but I did want to try the Chevron fuel because they are mixing TechronD into in my area. (I think this is the only area where this is being done in this country). I understand that this a pretty good detergent, so I want to see if it would clean up my black stuff.
 

ranger1

Veteran Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2005
Location
SouthEast
TDI
NA
This quote was taken from this site:

http://www.filtercouncil.org/techdata/faqs/faqdieselfuel.htm

> Q: What are asphaltenes?
>
> A: Asphaltenes are tarry, organic particles that naturally occur in #2 diesel fuels. Asphaltene particles are generally thought to be in the one-half to 2 micron range and are harmless to the injection system, as they are soft and deformable. Concentrations of asphaltenes in diesel fuel vary widely and can increase through heat and fuel oxidation. As these tiny particles pass through the filter media they tend to stick to individual fibers. A build up of asphaltenes is the normal mechanism that plugs diesel fuel filters, not hard particles.
> Reference FMC TSB-95-1R1
 

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
Since it seems that these black things increase through heat, does anyone have any opinion about whether bypassing the thermostatic T on the fuel filter could be helpful? I'm thinking that if the fuel filter doesn't get pre-heated, then cooler fuel going into the engine might equal cooler fuel coming out resulting in less particle formation (at least during the cooler seasons). I am thinking of using something like the Kerma Widget.
 

DanG144

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Location
Chapin, South Carolina, USA
TDI
2005 A4 Jetta 5spd
I think bypassing the thermo tee will have no effect.

Unless your thermo tee is not functioning, all the fuel bypasses the filter already when the fuel is warm.

With the fuel rails running through the head, we have trouble operating below the 90 C of the water jacket - and probably always will.

I would love to have a good fuel cooler before it goes to the filter (in summer anyway). This would need to have a thermostatically controlled bypass for winter operation.

I know some have done this.
 

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
I understand that the therm tee bypasses the fuel filter most of the time anyway. But it starts to do this after it has already warmed up the fuel filter (which probably doesn't take very long), thereby warming up the fuel that goes into the engine. My thought was that bypassing would take much longer to warm up the fuel filter, since the fuel goes through a fuel cooler on its way to the tank and so at least for the cooler seasons you would overall be seeing cooler fuel temperatures coming into the engine.

I understand that this might not give much benefit because the fuel will still get very hot once it gets into the engine head. I am just wondering if a decrease in incoming fuel temps will provide any noticeable decrease in outgoing fuel temps and associated black goo formation.
 

dhdenney

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Oct 23, 2005
Location
Kentucky
TDI
2012 Audi A3 TDI Ibis white
Just wanted to note that when I change my fuel filters I also observe a "blackening of the fuel." I use the little clear prefilters and those turn very black within a couple thousand miles. I would not be surprised to see the same condition inside my tank should I open it up.
 

Dimitri16V

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Location
DE
TDI
01 Golf, 04 Golf
fuel definitely gets darker after returning back to the tank.
Had a chance to observe this while using Diesel Purge in a clear bottle
 

DanG144

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Location
Chapin, South Carolina, USA
TDI
2005 A4 Jetta 5spd
The diesel purge flushes out a lot of the old gunk, so I would not judge by that. On some cars it will get really dark.

On several PD's that I have worked on, the fuel did not change noticeably in color on each pass through the system - but eventually the fuel in the tank was darker.
 

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
The first time I tried to diesel purge my PD, I used an in-line clear plastic fuel filter on the return line and could see black stuff filling it up. I didn't get very far into that can of diesel purge because the fuel was getting too hot. My connections were melting. That was before the 70,000 mile oil change. Before the 80,000 mile oil change, I filled a new fuel filter with one can of diesel purge and then connected a second can of diesel purge after the fuel filter and put that can in a bucket of ice. So the purge was pre-cooled and getting filtered on the way to the engine with a regular fuel filter. I didn't see any black stuff come out this time into the inch of diesel purge I left in the bottom the can. Maybe I got all the black gunk out the first time or maybe keeping it cool helped the fuel from turning black.
 

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
I was reading the Chevron website diesel paper and saw a discussion in it about the cetane improver 2-Ethylhexyl nitrate. The paper mentioned that the use of this additive can contribute to fuel degradation because the additive readily breaks down at high temperatures leaving nitrogen, oxygen and such in your fuel that gets re-circulated back to the tank. The breakdown products of the additive help accelerate the degradation of the fuel. The authors were also of the opinion that this was less likely to be a problem with ULSD, but didn't seem to have the evidence yet to demonstrate that. Here is a link to the paper: http://www.chevron.com/products/prodserv/fuels/documents/Diesel_Fuel_Tech_Review.pdf

I looked up the MSDS for the Stanadyne Performance Formula I had been using and it is 20-30% 2-Ethylhexyl nitrate. Diesel Purge also lists this ingredient on the side of the can. I don't know if it is in Power Service. It may also already be in any fuel I buy anyway because of the CARB diesel requirements where I live which requires high cetane or low aromatics. I am thinking that I will try not adding this additive to my tank as another measure to try to inhibit the fuel blackening.
 

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
I read through this and it looked interesting enough to include here and provides more information than the Chevron paper that I read through. It's a paper title Diesel Fuel Stability at 300F:http://www.fischer-tropsch.org/DOE/_conf_proc/MISC/Conf-971014-Vol%202/971014-Vol-2,%20Part%203,%20Pages%20671%20-%20773.pdf

Here are a couple of figures from the paper that show interesting findings:



and



What these figures show are thermal stability (on vertical axis) which is measured by how much black stuff ends up on a filter after heating the fuel for an amount of time. Higher %reflectance = cleaner filter = more stable. On the horizontal axis is concentration of 2-ethyl hexyl nitrate in parts per million. For comparison, the 20 to 30 percent 2-ethyl hexyl nitrate in stanadyne performance formula = 400 to 600 parts per million when added at the 1 to 500 parts treatment ratio. This paper concluded that higher concentrations of this additive resulted in less thermally stable fuel.
 
Last edited:

Geomorph

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Location
Sacramento, CA
TDI
2005 Golf and 2002 NB
So it looks like a combination of heat and the fuel additive may have contributed to the fuel blackening in my PD vs. VE. I can't do much about the heat in the PD, but I can at least stop adding additional 2-ethylhexyl nitrate and see if that helps. Any thoughts?
 
Top