Chevy Cruze Eco MPG

Joined
Oct 4, 2010
Location
Columbus, OH
TDI
2003
I saw a commericial yesterday for a Chevy Cruze Eco that gets 28 city and 42 hwy. That is very close to the 30/42 that the 2011 Jetta TDI is posting. At about $8,000 less than the TDI, along with the lower cost of gas vs diesel, combined with the natural "issues" that come with owning a euro diesel (labor and parts costs, reduced number of diesel stations, winter cold starts, etc. etc.) all I can say is that VW better get the Polo TDI here ASAP, because although it is still better in my opinion, it is quickly becoming less and less practical to buy the TDI.
 
Joined
Oct 4, 2010
Location
Columbus, OH
TDI
2003
I hear that. Its worth noting however that the cars made by the Big 3 are notably better after 2009 than before. I'm not even saying the TDI's are worse, they are better. You, I, and everyone on this site knows it...but if VW wants people to go diesel they need to offer up something more than 2mpg city in exchange for $8000 higher price tag and a higher cost of fuel. 2mpg + $8000 +higher fuel cost + higher repair cost vs. Same gas millage, lower fuel costs, lower repair costs...even with the argument of the diesel lasting longer, most people aren't looking to run their car into the ground. After about 150,000 miles or so people start looking to upgrade to something newer. I bet 90% of people will go for the Chevy in a side by side choice. And considering that most people have bad perceptions about diesels and many don't even know that a diesel car is an option in the States, that number could be higher.
 
Last edited:

MrMopar

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Mar 1, 2003
Location
Bloomington, IL
TDI
none
With the Cruze ECO, I hope you don't mind not having a spare tire . . .

Cruze MSRP = $19,175 (auto transmission is $925 extra)
Jetta MSRP = $23,765 (DSG transmission is $1,100 extra)
Both those prices include delivery. That's a price spread of $4,590, not $8,000.

The price on the Cruze is higher than what most people expect to pay for a compact car. At any rate the 42 mpg in the Cruze comes with having a gasser engine featuring less torque. The driving experience of a TDI is more relaxing and satisfying than the Cruze gasoline engine due to the torque output of the engine. Cruze = 138 hp, 150 lb-ft; TDI = 140 hp, 236 lb-ft. Compare both of those cars and you get almost twice the torque with the Jetta as you do with the Cruze.

You also have to deal with EPA mileage figures that are sometimes hard to attain. The Cruze will probably only see 40+ MPG under ideal conditions but lots of people with diesel engines will easily meet or surpass the fuel economy figures once their engine is broken in well.
 

MrMopar

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Mar 1, 2003
Location
Bloomington, IL
TDI
none
IAfter about 150,000 miles or so people start looking to upgrade to something newer.
And smart buyers, similar to buying a house, look at potential residual value. In the past TDI cars have held much higher resale values at any mileage over their gasoline counterparts.
 
Joined
Oct 4, 2010
Location
Columbus, OH
TDI
2003
My mistake with the $8000. Go Google "Chevy Cruze Eco" and you the first thing that comes up is "2011 Chevy Cruze ECO"...but that link does not take you to the ECO page..I assumed it had. MrMopar, I'm all with you. Understand that my point is not that the TDI is not better, but the average consumer will not look at ft. lbs. of torque when shopping...hell there is even a phrase to go along with that "people buy HP but drive torque". With the resale value of the car, they have indeed held up higher than the gassers, but how much of that has to do with the huge difference in MPG. I mean the MKIVs, like mine, get 50+mpg whereas a 2003 grand-am gets like 28....huge difference. Huge. I'm not all too confidant that a TDI will be worth so much more in resale if it gets 2mpg city better...remember for many people buying a used car, cost is an issue (not for all, some people just don't like buying a new car because they get a better deal with a slightly used but depreciated car). Either way my point remains the same, VW needs to get the Polo over here because as nice as it is that the Jetta gets twice as many lbs of torque, the average consumer does not care. And the big selling point in any car today is MPG.
 

BretAZ

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2011
Location
Surprise, Arizona
TDI
2011 Jetta TDI
The real world difference in price is even less. My neighbor just paid full MSRP for a Cruz Eco, nobody would deal. My Jetta was $23,765 and I picked it up for $21,990. He paid somewhere just shy of $20,000. In my opinion, the only two things these cars had in common was MPG. The Jetta is bigger, more confortable, and more features for only a little more money. In terms of reliability and service, they both are probably comparable. But the edge for me went to the TDI.

The biggest reason to not buy the Cruze for me was I would get tired of friends asking me why I was driving a rental car.

I actually like the Cruze, just not $20,000 worth.
 

MrMopar

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Mar 1, 2003
Location
Bloomington, IL
TDI
none
I actually like the Cruze, just not $20,000 worth.
See, I have the same opinion.

Call me a typical American but I have been conditioned by a decade of domestic car manufacturers rolling out giant rebates, financing and good discounts off MSRP to keep people buying American cars. Selling me a $20,000 Chevy sedan? It better come with a $4,000 rebate and 0.9% financing if you expect me to pick that over a Honda Accord.

Chevy had the Cobalt as the American-built small car that was "better" than the Cavalier it replaced. The pre-production models shown off to Motor Trend and C&D years ago had GM practically begging them to publish good things about the cars with a promise that they were tweaking things and this time the cars were going to be really good and not designed solely by cost-cutting bean counters. Well, they constantly finished at the bottom of comparisons.

Now they're selling the same thing with the Cruze. This time it is getting good reviews but both MT and C&D are saying "What is up with the $20,000 price?" The Cruze is a Honda Civic analog - a small car that's supposed to be efficient and reliable. Well, GM had a lot of years of cars being unreliable and it will take a serious effort over the next decade to convince the American buying public that their cars are reliable over the long term. Until then they should expect to compete on price and what remaining "Buy American" sentiment they have left.
 

schwarze Käfer

Veteran Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2010
Location
Texas (panhandle)
TDI
2003 New Beetle GLS 5spd
And GM (government motors) backs a plan to add $1/gal fuel tax? Why? To sell more Cruzes/Volts? Reason enough NOT to buy anything GM.

x2 Brian - Ford anytime!
 
Last edited:

MonsterTDI09

TDIClub Enthusiast, Veteran Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2009
Location
NoVa/NJ
TDI
2010 Jetta DSG/ up keep on 2009 Jetta DSG 2006 Jetta Pag 2 in North SEA Green
Does the Chevy Cruze need Hi octane fuel, to get that mileage
 

tdi90hp

Veteran Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2002
Location
Canuckland
TDI
2011 Golf TDI 6 speed(gone but NEVER forgotten)
I'd take a Focus (hatch!) over a Cruze any day of the week ...
I drove a 6 speed ECO a few weeks ago for 30 miles or so....the car is flat out amazing....quiet, quiet, quiet, well built, shifts nice and revs super low on hwy....not as much torque in tall gears but dont discount this car and feels very well screwed together.......sorry the 5 speed base focus for 2-3 K less does not compare...real basic. still think the Golf Highline feels like a lot more car but we paid almost 7K more in Canada than a Cruze...although our car has a lot more equipment...I like GMs warranty as well....100,000 miles on powertrain is nothing to sneeze at.
 

BretAZ

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2011
Location
Surprise, Arizona
TDI
2011 Jetta TDI
See, I have the same opinion.
Call me a typical American but I have been conditioned by a decade of domestic car manufacturers rolling out giant rebates, financing and good discounts off MSRP to keep people buying American cars. Selling me a $20,000 Chevy sedan? It better come with a $4,000 rebate and 0.9% financing if you expect me to pick that over a Honda Accord.
Chevy had the Cobalt as the American-built small car that was "better" than the Cavalier it replaced. The pre-production models shown off to Motor Trend and C&D years ago had GM practically begging them to publish good things about the cars with a promise that they were tweaking things and this time the cars were going to be really good and not designed solely by cost-cutting bean counters. Well, they constantly finished at the bottom of comparisons.
Now they're selling the same thing with the Cruze. This time it is getting good reviews but both MT and C&D are saying "What is up with the $20,000 price?" The Cruze is a Honda Civic analog - a small car that's supposed to be efficient and reliable. Well, GM had a lot of years of cars being unreliable and it will take a serious effort over the next decade to convince the American buying public that their cars are reliable over the long term. Until then they should expect to compete on price and what remaining "Buy American" sentiment they have left.
GM has always competed with price. Its all they had. They could probably learn a thing or two from Hyundai if they would just open their eyes. Hyundai overcame all the bad memories of those first Hyundai Excels. Today, Hyundai is pretty well regarded. But first they had to prove themselves. GM should be doing the same thing. I guess some people are willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. I am not. I will keep my $20k.
 

sfierz

Veteran Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2001
Location
Rockford, Illinois
TDI
1996 Tornado Red Passat
I don't know, I drove a Ford Focus rental car a month ago and it was a pretty nice car. Interior was basic, but nice. Stereo had satellite and bluetooth, and the car was pretty zoomy. I expected it to get 30 MPG but it got 42 MPG cruising 80 MPH on a 300 mile trip to Detroit. The CVT transmission was smooth and shifts were crisp. Only omission that I could see was a lack of cruise control. But, it may have been a basic model since it was a rental. It also was a little "darty" on the freeway. Good car, otherwise, and probably only $15k MSRP.

I'd take a Focus (hatch!) over a Cruze any day of the week ...
 

GoFaster

Moderator at Large
Joined
Jun 16, 1999
Location
Brampton, Ontario, Canada
TDI
2006 Jetta TDI
Ford Focus does not have a CVT transmission. If it was automatic (and given that it was a rental car in North America, that's practically a certainty), it is a 6-speed dual-clutch transmission which is not unlike VW's DSG automatic. That's why it "shifts" ... CVT transmissions don't "shift" unless the programming is faking it, which some of them do ...

And what's the point of having a driver KNEE airbag?? If the driver is wearing their seat belt, I can't see any purpose in having this, and if the driver is not wearing their seat belt, they deserve whatever is coming to them!!
 

sfierz

Veteran Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2001
Location
Rockford, Illinois
TDI
1996 Tornado Red Passat
Ok, DSG then. I didn't know exactly what type of trans it was but it wasn't a traditional slush box. I liked it.


Ford Focus does not have a CVT transmission. If it was automatic (and given that it was a rental car in North America, that's practically a certainty), it is a 6-speed dual-clutch transmission which is not unlike VW's DSG automatic. That's why it "shifts" ... CVT transmissions don't "shift" unless the programming is faking it, which some of them do ...

And what's the point of having a driver KNEE airbag?? If the driver is wearing their seat belt, I can't see any purpose in having this, and if the driver is not wearing their seat belt, they deserve whatever is coming to them!!
 

chemist93

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
Location
Morganton, NC
TDI
'03 New Beetle
After reading the brochure on the Cruze ECO, I thought it got better mileage with a manual tranny and a tall overdrive 6th gear.
 

MrMopar

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Mar 1, 2003
Location
Bloomington, IL
TDI
none
If you want a comparison of cheap fuel efficient cars you would do well to look at the new 2012 Hyundai Accent. It is $13,500 with a 6-speed manual, has moved up in interior size to "compact" car status, and the 1.6 liter I-4 engine now has GDI to attain 40 MPG highway/30 MPG city. Air conditioning comes with the automatic transmission (don't know if AC is available as a separate option) so the cost goes up a bit to make it comparable to a Jetta.
 

audi_racer017

Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2011
Location
NC
TDI
Jetta TD, Audi GT
With the Cruze ECO, I hope you don't mind not having a spare tire . . .

Cruze MSRP = $19,175 (auto transmission is $925 extra)
Jetta MSRP = $23,765 (DSG transmission is $1,100 extra)
Both those prices include delivery. That's a price spread of $4,590, not $8,000.
How about comparing your above with - smaller compact in Ford's lineup:
Fiesta Se 1.6L - $20 429 (auto $1 200) boasts 41 city/ 55 hwy. falls between the Cruze or the Jetta
 

rotarykid

Top Post Dawg
Joined
Apr 27, 2003
Location
Piedmont of N.C. & the plains of Colorado
TDI
1997 Passat TDI White,99.5 Blue Jetta TDI
I was at a VW dealer Thursday afternoon and they had 6 2 dr Golf TDIs ( half man and half DSGs ) with stickers of ~$25k, a couple a little under and couple a little over. One surprise was the DSG had no surcharge over the 6 spd man car, sticker listed both the 6 spd man and DSG free of charge.

And I have a hard time buying the Cruize's EPA's claimed highway mpgs. In the real world I expect the mpgs to be in the high 30s at best.
 

BRUSSELS BELGIAN

Old Whig
Joined
May 26, 1999
Location
Aston,Pa. USA
TDI
1997 Passat TDI
A Future Hall of Famer

Well, I like to rain on everyone's parade. The Cruz Eco got 48+ mpg @ 60 mph under the FAT right foot of USA Today's Kevin Healy. He also claims it has the best manual gearbox of ANY car for sale in America today, regardless of price. What this thing is, is a "gasser" TDI, if you look at the small, turbocharged engine pulling a numerically low drive ratio. This car is an all-star...
 

tdi90hp

Veteran Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2002
Location
Canuckland
TDI
2011 Golf TDI 6 speed(gone but NEVER forgotten)
I was at a VW dealer Thursday afternoon and they had 6 2 dr Golf TDIs ( half man and half DSGs ) with stickers of ~$25k, a couple a little under and couple a little over. One surprise was the DSG had no surcharge over the 6 spd man car, sticker listed both the 6 spd man and DSG free of charge.

And I have a hard time buying the Cruize's EPA's claimed highway mpgs. In the real world I expect the mpgs to be in the high 30s at best.

one should read before making big statements.....this writer for the TO star got slightly BETTER mileage than (about 3-4%) than we get with similar mix in driving.....yesssss....better....GM is fighting hard for this 20K eco car market and this eco Cruze is a good hard hit triple at least.....
 
Top